StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Discipline in the Public Schools - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper 'Discipline in the Public Schools' tells that Public schools are important institutions for shaping the personalities and imparting education to children at a younger level. Few current cases and rulings of public schools are discussed in this paper with the justification and analysis…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Discipline in the Public Schools
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Discipline in the Public Schools"

Discipline in the Public Schools: An Analysis Public schools are important s for shaping the personalities as well as imparting the education to children at a younger level. Few current cases and rulings of public schools are discussed in this paper with the justification and analysis of each. Tinker vs Des Moines Independent School District (1969): The case took place between the Tinker family and the Des Moines Independent School District in which these students were studying at that time. The Tinker family was the petitioner, and the school district was the respondent. (TINKER vs DES MOINES DISTRICT SCHOOL) It was in 1965 when John tinker his sister Mary Tinker and a friend Chris Eckhardt wore black armbands on their sleeve in protest of the Vietnam War. The school faculty told them to remove those armbands, but they refused. As a consequence, John, Mary Tinker and Chris Eckhardt were suspended. (TINKER vs DES MOINES DISTRICT SCHOOL) The Tinker family protested and the sued the school district saying that they had violated the students right of Freedom of speech (Jacobs). The case was tried at Supreme Court, and the Tinker family won the case. The Supreme Court gave the ruling that the school official do not "shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate" (TINKER vs DES MOINES DISTRICT SCHOOL). However, the court further added that the right of freedom of choice must be maintained within the limits. It should not in any way disturb class activity or invade rights of others. The impact of this case had been huge for the next years and many times the Tinker reference was used in courts. One such instance was when Mathew Fraser of Bethel High School was suspended by the school for giving a speech containing sexual innuendos. The court, however, favored the school and the suspension was upheld a speech containing sexual innuendos. The court remarked that it was fair of the school to suspend the student for using vulgar language within school boundaries. (Jacobs) The Tinker case edges on the boundary of what is right and what is not. It depends on the situation and the way people use their rights given to them by the constitution. The Tinker family wore black armbands in dispute of the war against Vietnam, but it was not invasion of school guidelines that are handed to students. War is means of destruction, no matter for whatever reasons it is fought. It takes lives of innocent people. It has been seen today that even football players wear black armbands to condemn racism. In 2002, people went out on the streets to condemn attacks on Afghanistan, but it was only a movement in which people took part (Pinto). Nothing violent took place. Same was the case with Tinker family they just wore armbands in protest of the war and possibly to side more students with them and show the State that the youth is not supporting the cause. It was not any act of violence. There was huge unrest among the American public in response to the Vietnam War, in general. (Hodbodova). So, the Tinker family stood right in the case. If the case was tried in 2012, the decision would have stayed the same. In the twenty first century, people have much more freedom of choice and speech. We have seen many times people coming out on the street and not supporting the cause, such as the War against Terror in Afghanistan (Pinto). Goss vs Lopez: Administrators of Colombus, Ohio, Public School System-CPSS, appealed against the ruling of three-judge federal court that was in favor of high school temporarily suspended students of CPSS, on the grounds that Fourteen Amendment was violated for a chance of hearing was not afforded to them. The ruling directed that reference to suspensions to be removed from the record of the students. (GOSS ET AL. v. LOPEZ ET AL.) The judgment had evoked Section 3313.66 of Ohio State (that provides free education to children of 5-21) which states that the Principal of a public school can, either suspend a pupil for up to 10 days or expel him/her. In case of expulsion, the parents are to be informed who can appeal to the Board of Education which after hearing can reinstate of uphold Principal’s judgment. There is no provision of hearing for the suspended students and the nine suspenders were denied of Fourteen Amendment. (GOSS ET AL. v. LOPEZ ET AL.) The appellants contested that education at public expense was not a constitutional right so the Due Process Law cannot guard against expulsion for the state statutes or rules protect against property rights. The ruling stated that the appeal lees cannot be denied the fundamental right to education. (GOSS ET AL. v. LOPEZ ET AL.) The appellants put forth that right to education of the Clause can be evoked in case the student is subjected to “the severe detriment or grievous loss” and 10 days of suspension do not fall in this category. This was refuted on the grounds that education is the foremost function of the State even 10 days of suspension could have serious effects on the child. (GOSS ET AL. v. LOPEZ ET AL.) Hence, after the court maintained that due process applied it embarked on the process to be adopted by the public schools. It acknowledged that, for smooth disciplined administration, suspensions or expulsions may be required, but it is the duty of the disciplinarian to inform the student of his/her misconduct and also to give an opportunity of hearing as well. Notice of early hearing to be served to the student except in cases where a student is a direct threat to the academic system can be immediately expelled. The suspended students be given notice to hear his/her version in order to avoid any erroneous decisions by the disciplinarians. More formal procedures may be required in case of long suspensions or term or permanent expulsions. I uphold the verdict on the following grounds: 1. Justice unheard is justice denied. No matter how trivial a punishment one should be given a chance to present his/her point of view. 2. Education is a fundamental right of each citizen and one should not be debarred on personal judgments. 3. Temporary misconduct related suspensions may not only create an emotional stigma for the student but if recorded his/her chances of higher education will be bleak. New Jersey vs T.L.O: The case was regarding the invasion of private rights of a student. The petitioner T.L.O, Terry, was caught smoking in the bathroom by a teacher. She was taken to the Principal, who then asked to check her purse (Jacobs). Upon checking her bag, cigarettes and marijuana was found. Consequently, police was called, and Terry was convicted for usage and selling of drugs. Terry pleaded, and her case was taken to Supreme Court. The court favored the school by remarking that students have "Legitimate expectations of privacy but that must be balanced with the schools responsibility for maintaining environments in which learning can take place."". (New Jersey v. T.L.O.) The Court took a fair decision because it was not due to vendetta of the teacher against the student of any kind that he tried to search for her bag; instead she was caught smoking, and as it was not permissible within school premises. So, it was every right of the faculty to search for the bag so that they may have significant proof against the student to suspend or expel her. The decision of the Court would have been the same as it is still not permissible for students to smoke within school premises, so obviously they would be checked if they had been caught and the same verdict would have stood. References GOSS ET AL. v. LOPEZ ET AL. No. 419 U.S. 565 . SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES. 22 January 1975. Hodbodova, Zuzana. The Vietnam War, Public Opinion and American . Diploma Thesis. Brno: MASARYK UNIVERSITY BRNO, 2008. Jacobs, Tom. 10 Supreme Court Cases Every Teen Should Know. New York, 15 September 2008. New Jersey v. T.L.O. No. 469 U.S. 325. SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES. 28 March 1984. Pinto, Jennifer De. Publics Views of Afghanistan War Have Turned Sour. Washington, October 2009. TINKER vs DES MOINES DISTRICT SCHOOL. No. 393 US 503. United States Supreme Court. 24 February 1969. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Discipline in the Public Schools Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 1, n.d.)
Discipline in the Public Schools Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words - 1. https://studentshare.org/education/1778507-discipline-in-the-public-schools
(Discipline in the Public Schools Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 1)
Discipline in the Public Schools Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/education/1778507-discipline-in-the-public-schools.
“Discipline in the Public Schools Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words - 1”. https://studentshare.org/education/1778507-discipline-in-the-public-schools.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Discipline in the Public Schools

Children Should Never Be Educated at Home by Their Parents

Many parents who regularly home school their children claim that they do not agree with the morals that are encouraged, or which go unchecked in public schools.... Most parents do not have a good grasp of all the different subjects that are taught in public schools such as calculus, Drama, Trigonometry, Biology, Psychology, and Instrumental Music (Windley 22).... Parents have no real substitute for the exposure that children get in public schools....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Department of Defense Education Activity

Relatively, children from DoDEA who are well disciplined also perform academically better than those of their counterparts in the local public schools since they are rigorously required to come up with the high standard of the school and excel in their marks (Randolph 1-2).... t also goes true that DoDEA students or children have a wholesome sense of security which really sets them apart from the students enrolled in conventional public schools.... Children who hail or are from schools managed by the Department of Defense Education Activity or DoDEA have total advantages of being well disciplined, achievers and safety conscious....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Cultural Issues in Public Schools

public schools form one of the basic entities within which people, and especially pupils and students acquire new cultures, or have their cultures re-instilled within their system.... public schools engage people in promoting cultural competence, as well as, linguistic necessary… The diversity of students, teachers, and workers; present a complex set up of people with varying languages; complexion, cultural values, personalities; amongst other differences. Anthropology is entails scientific study of human culture as well as their biological CULTURAL ISSUES IN public schools IntroductionPublic schools form one of the basic entities within which people, and especially pupils and students acquire new cultures, or have their cultures re-instilled within their system....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Uniforms in Public Schools and the First Amendment: A Constitutional Analysis

The following essay presents standardized arguments for the article "Uniforms in public schools and the First Amendment: A Constitutional Analysis" by Mitchel, H.... nbsp; Standardized ArgumentsUniforms in public schools and the First Amendment: A Constitutional AnalysisIntroductionThe following essay will present standardized arguments for the article on: uniforms in public school and the first amendment: a constitutional analysis.... Uniforms in public schools and the First Amendment: A Constitutional Analysis....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Critical Reflection Journal.School to Prison Pipeline

The pipeline… This problem has been propagated by shortages in staffing and statutory mandates in the public schools.... This problem has been propagated by shortages in staffing and statutory mandates in the public schools.... Some students have been sent to disciplinary alternative schools and juvenile detention after being expelled from the public schools.... Most public schools suffer from lack of enough resources, for example, lack of enough and qualified teachers, insufficient funds, overcrowded classrooms, lack of counselors, and lack special education facilities among others....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

School Dress Codes and Uniforms

Despite the displeasure of the opponents, many Schools have already started making uniforms mandatory in Kentucky sharply contrasting to majority of public schools showing reluctance to the same.... That reason of limited research on the relationship of dress code and the factors above and the public demand for absolute knowledge on the area will form the basis of this research.... Due to increased gang-related activities, relatively poor performance and the need to keep schools safe and non-discriminatory, there have been attempts to introduce policies aimed at achieving these state without having to violate human rights of the stakeholders while also not involving police all the time....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Education and Law

hellip; Generally speaking, every teacher must know that discipline and physical or verbal abuses are permissible or impermissible depending on the legislation, and a professional code of conduct affected.... would discipline Johnny Crusade for displaying offensive language during Senate action....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Educating and Disciplining Children or Students

nbsp; The sentiment expressed by the members of the public saw the civil rights attorney taking matters to court by suing the state for negligence and biases.... Integrated schools tend to perform better than the sidelined schools.... nbsp;Further, the provided data from the California report indicate that discipline was the solution for a student that depicted defiant behavior....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us