StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The effectiveness of pay for performance plan - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The pay for performance model or merit pay system has been used for many decades in fields such as sales and managerial positions in a diverse array of industries. It has served well in many instances to motivate individuals through monetary incentives or bonuses in order to achieve a superior level of production or sales performance…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
The effectiveness of pay for performance plan
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The effectiveness of pay for performance plan"

Download file to see previous pages

Not every employee is the same; therefore their preferences and motivating factors are as varied as their individual personalities. Utilizing, combining, and integrating the right compensation strategy in the corporate structure plays a critical role in maintaining employee motivation, retaining talent, and attracting high-performing candidates to the company. Although pay for performance compensation plans have always played an integral role in the compensation package of many companies there are a number of shortcomings related to the merit pay system.

Traditional compensation models ignore the key emotional influencers that reveal an individual’s key motivating factors. According to a recent paper called “The Psychological Costs of Pay-for-Performance”, by Ian Larkin, Lamar Pierce of Harvard and Francesca Gino of Washington University, this working paper identify the psychological costs of how social comparison, employee overconfidence, and loss aversion are prime determinants of the success and viability of individual performance-based compensation systems (Tighe, 2011).

“Social comparison is the tendency of individuals to compare their pay vs. effort ratio with their peers and their expectations of their compensation to be “fair” based on these preconceived notions. As a result of this comparisons pay plan effectiveness or perceived fairness is often compromised. Individuals commonly judge the extent of other people’s work contribution based on what they can see and not on actual results. Consequently coworkers are often unfairly judged since the value or true extent of their work is performed off premises or behind closed doors such as with salespeople or executives.

Although in the case of major CEO’s or star athletes for instance pay becomes a social measuring stick to which they compare against their peers, so pay becomes more closely tied to social factors and not necessarily economics. Employee overconfidence is where individuals have the tendency to overestimate their own abilities and skill set therefore they are prone to accepting tasks above their capabilities. According to Larkin; “Psychologists and decision research scholars have long noted that people tend to be overconfident about their own abilities and too optimistic about their future.

"; "Recent research has shown that overconfidence is not as much an individual personality trait as it is a bias that affects most people"(Tighe, 2011). The authors elaborate that in general people tend to be overconfident in their ability to complete tasks that they tend to perform frequently. On the other hand individuals tend to underestimate their ability to complete tasks which they are not familiar with or seem too complex. Since pay-for-performance systems are based on the ability of individuals to pick and choose positions that they feel best matches their skill set, the misalignment between the individual’s perception of themselves and their true skill set can cause them to undertake projects or tasks that are beyond their capabilities (Tighe, 2011).

Instead of pay-for-performance becoming a catalyst for increased organizational achievement and individual performance an employee’s overconfidence can cause them to underperform under pressure, increase general dissatisfaction, and can also bring about a

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The effectiveness of pay for performance plan Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1417947-the-effectiveness-of-pay-for-performance-plan
(The Effectiveness of Pay for Performance Plan Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1417947-the-effectiveness-of-pay-for-performance-plan.
“The Effectiveness of Pay for Performance Plan Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1417947-the-effectiveness-of-pay-for-performance-plan.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The effectiveness of pay for performance plan

Designing Reward Practices To Influence Employee Behavior

pay for performance acts as one of the most suitable motivational factors for the employees.... hellip; This article can help to understand better of what reward practices actually are and why is it important for the managers of a company to implement a suitable reward/incentive plan for the employees.... The essay will also discuss some of the key issues that the managers of a company need to consider when designing an incentive plan for the employees....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Performance management

But the hard fact is, it is lot easier said than done, and therefore, strategic planning of all the factors is considered before implementing performance enhancer's techniques in the organisation.... Therefore, as PWC is responsible for a few of the works that are associated with the government, it is very important for the organisation to be ideal in the performance department.... The Role and Nature of performance Management Systems in PWC The core principles of PWC are achieving excellence, developing teamwork and inspiring leadership....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Pay for Performance

Therefore, effectiveness of pay for performance can be measured with surveys aims at findings about employee satisfaction and motivation levels (Gomez-Mejia, 2010).... If any pay for performance plan is motivating employees but not adding to the financial success of the company then it is better for the company to revisit the plan and the processes (Schuler & Jackson, 2007).... There are many advantages of pay for performance programs for the employees and that is why many companies opt for it....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Improving Performance and Organizational Effectiveness

IMPROVING performance AND ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS by [your name goes here] Presented to [your goes here] [your class name goes here] [your university's name] [due date of the paper] Introduction The Fortune 500 is the list of top 500 companies of the United States.... Improving employees' performance and increasing organization effectiveness are two of the major aims of the Fortune 500 companies.... In this paper, we will discuss how Fortune 500 companies can achieve their goals of improving employees' performance and organizational effectiveness....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Performance Management

In this regard, motivation level of employees at a restaurant can be assessed by Moreover, assessment of standards of such places can play a vital role in the identification of status of performance management system.... It is observed that all such rate errors facilitate in better carrying out of behavioral assessment process that are key to understand the status of performance in an organization.... For instance, ratings for the entire period can be influenced by the performance in the beginning of such period through identification of primacy rate error....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

HR Headline: Pay for Performance in Public Schools Remains Controversial

This means that the plan would be pay for performance plan Introduction A pay-for-performance plan is an incentive plan that aims at rewarding highlyproductive employees with higher income.... Measurement of effectiveness of pay-for-Performance PlansIt is essential to measure the effectiveness of the plan appropriate for a particular business to ensure that the goals of such organization are met.... t is also possible to determine the effectiveness of the plan by determining job satisfaction among company's employees....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Compensation Plan Outline

The term “compensation plan” in a company refers to combination of salaries, wages, and all types of benefits employees receive in exchange of good performance.... Compensation plans mainly refer to all these components and the mode of payment and the purpose in which employees receive The following is an outline of Kellogg's compensation plan.... In order to motivate its employees, the company has come up with a compensation plan, which provides eligible workers with a competitive form of retirement benefits depending on the years of service and pay and improve the performance of the employees....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

The Effectiveness of Pay for Performance Programs

This paper “the effectiveness of pay for performance Programs” aims at improving the performance of current employees, retaining them in the organization, prevailing fair treatment and equality and attracting new promising employees in order to achieve the organization's short term and long term goals.... Various theories and studies are there to support the effectiveness of pay for performance programs.... The expectancy theory also discusses certain conditions which foster the use of pay for performance programs in order to achieve desired performance which includes that; the employees comprehend the plan performance goals as achievable, the relation between performance and pay is easy to understand and is made known to all concerned employees, the employees value the reward and find the link between performance outcome and reward size as satisfactory (John Edward....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us