StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis The case of Emeh v. Kensington and Chelsea and Westminster Area Health Authority1 is submersed in a sea of decisions relating to the ability of parents to recover damages for the birth of their unwanted child…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.8% of users find it useful
The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis"

Download file to see previous pages

case a blessing.3 The circumstances posed to the Court of Appeal in Emeh required that it find some form of reconciliation between the two different stances of Udale and of Thake, though it was distinct from these two cases because the child had been born with disabilities. As a result, the damages awarded were restricted to those extra costs incurred as a result of the unwanted child’s disabilities, though the court claimed that it had awarded full costs. The approach as contained in Damages for the Birth of a Child4 suggests that Emeh was a result of the equation of unwanted pregnancy with consequential economic loss, and the damages were thus calculated according to “reasonably foreseeable financial loss directly caused by the unexpected pregnancy”.

5 This approach was arguably taken too far in the decision of Benarr & Another v. Kettering Health Authority6in which it was held that damages could extend to private education of the unwanted child. . the courts in relation to the decision of Emeh, and Ognall J in a subsequent similar case expressed his discomfort with a law that awards damages to the mother of a child, particularly if it is healthy; he said: “but there it is: that is the law”.8 Although the approach of the courts appears to be undecided on this matter, it is argued by some that awarding damages for both healthy and disabled unwanted children is perfectly acceptable according to principles of tort law,9 though decisions of the court have disagreed with this contention.

10 There appears to be a major problem surrounding the distinction between unwanted healthy children and unwanted disabled children, and whether full or partial damages are to be awarded to both.11 It is suggested that the failure of the court in McFarlane to restrict its application to disabled children has caused an array of confusing exceptions to be created by subsequent cases on the topic.12 Yet what is the public policy behind the approach of the courts? It was claimed in Rees v Darlington Memorial Hospital NHS Trust13 that there are major public policy implications for making public bodies that are funded by the public to pay large sums of money to parents of healthy children.

14 Such an approach has claimed that awarding damages for healthy unwanted children simply takes the law of tort “too far”.15 While this would seem to be a reasonably grounded policy which aims to establish the importance of causing healthy unwanted pregnancies and unhealthy unwanted pregnancies, highlighting the graver financial (and psychological) inconvenience of the latter, it has attracted much criticism.16 Such criticism is however warranted if one is to view the normal application of tort law which functions to award damages to healthy

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1437923-medicine-and-the-law
(The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1437923-medicine-and-the-law.
“The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1437923-medicine-and-the-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Problem of Unwanted Births and the Awarding of Damages on a Public Policy Basis

Environmental Problems and Role of International, European Community, and Domestic Laws for Environment Protection

Environmental laws have been proposed by the concerned authorities to address the problem in most efficient manner.... Problems relate to environment are not only confined to local regions, but this problem has reached up to global level adding complexities in daily routine of people and imposing further health related issues at other side.... They have suggested various suitable methods and strategic tools to deal with the problems of environment without increasing risk factors for any other problem....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Abortion representation in the media: The UK and the US in comparative perspective

After the commencement of abortion law in UK in 1967, the censorship policy was reviewed and hence many controversial yet factual aspects became a part of media coverage or main themes of the customary programs.... Although, the connotation of media on the society is evident, as the information retrieved from it, was and is to some extent considered authentic without the need of verification by the general public.... Hence, the general public has adapted irresponsible attitude towards unborn human life and with the aid and legalization of government towards abortion, they tend to discard their pregnancies, which happens due to their own languor and negligent behavior (Wilson, 2013)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Dissertation

Corporate Environmental Management Issues

public pressure for good environmental governance had increased at the time of the leaky tank incident.... The assignment "Corporate Environmental Management Issues" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues concerning corporate environmental management.... nbsp;Xerox leadership is committed to creating an environmentally sound company....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

International Law and Mega Energy Projects

These energy mega projects are not independent of laws on the basis of which the economic growth is evitable.... International law does not only work as the mediator between the disputed parties that are the public and the stake holders of energy mega projects but also as the regulator in this diplomatic act....
27 Pages (6750 words) Essay

Factors on Attitudes of Binge Drinking among Young Adults in the United Kingdom

This dissertation attempts to identify the influencing factors associated with attitudes of binge drinking which can have an impact on marketing for educating the public and designing interventions for positively influencing young adults.... The phenomenon of binge drinking usually translates into scenes involving young people of both sexes struggling along on public streets, young men and women being noisily sick on the streets at late hours, fights and brawls of the most barbarous character...
46 Pages (11500 words) Essay

Strategic Business Analysis

billion, physical security £331 million, police and public services £63 million and manned security £1.... The first study that looked at non-public policing sector was perhaps that undertaken during the 1980s by Stephen and Shannon, which investigated the increasing significance of the private security industry in Canada (Stephen and Shannon 1981, 1982, 1995).... The next stage of research was the recognition there was also a wide range of voluntary, public sector and quasi-public sector organizations engaged in security management (Chandler 1962; Stern and Stalk 1998)....
32 Pages (8000 words) Essay

English Tort Law and Employers Liability Act 1969

This essay analyzes the English Tort Law.... The tort of trespass of battery has three elements: force, direct application of force, and intent to directly apply that force to another.... Any touching of another person's body can amount to a battery if done without the consent of that other party....
68 Pages (17000 words) Essay

Developing a Security Plan

hellip; Information security protects such information from any tampering or damages.... The author of the paper "Developing a Security Plan" will begin with the statement that information security is the safeguarding of information and information systems.... This is done to ensure that only authorized people get to access such information or use it....
15 Pages (3750 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us