StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Advise Goldcorp Ltd - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In a world of huge and expanding businesses,everyone utilizes his right to protect his business and property.The Retention of Title is one of such clauses in a business agreement that enable a seller of goods to protect his monitory and property interests…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Advise Goldcorp Ltd
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Advise Goldcorp Ltd"

?Advise Goldcorp Ltd. as to their prospects of successfully relying on their Retention of (RoT) clause to recover the goods d above and proceeds of sale In a world of huge and expanding businesses, everyone utilizes his right to protect his business and property. The Retention of Title (RoT) is one of such clauses in a business agreement that enable a seller of goods to protect his monitory and property interests; in case the goods purchasing company suffers bankruptcy. The RoT clause is an agreement that allows the seller of goods to hold ownership/retain title, of the goods until the occurrence of a specified/agreed event; that event being either the payment of supplied goods, or payment of all money owed1. By agreeing to the RoT clause the buyer of the product agrees that until payment of the purchased goods is made the company that is selling the goods holds ownership claim to the goods, and hence can exert that claim anytime it wants. This allows the selling company to protect its investment. During the insolvency proceedings, a RoT ensures return of owed money which otherwise is highly unlikely under the circumstances2. Goldcorp Ltd. has been in regular business with GT Jewelers. Both entered into doing business with each other by signing an agreement that also included a RoT clause, of which both parties were aware. After the GT Jewelers failed to remit payment for the months of September and October while Delivery had been made, Gold Corp Ltd. enforced a RoT to the GT Jewelers. Under the RoT, Gold Corp Ltd have claimed the ownership of: 1 kilo of gold in their vault, stamped with Goldcorp Ltd’s seals, A tank containing 2 kilos of melted gold bullion, 150 gold and diamond engagement rings worth ?5,000 each, and ?25,000 representing proceeds of sale of gold by GT Jewellers Ltd to another jewellery manufacturer. Gold Corp cannot rely heavily and positively on their RoT to claim their goods/money. The absence of certain clauses makes Gold Corp an unsecured creditor thus making the chances of receiving owed payment meak. The Rot fulfills the first most condition of being a valid contract since it was agreed upon by both parties before the business. There are scenarios which can either render the RoT ineffective or simply lead to its termination, the RoT does not consist of any clause signifying the conditions under which the RoT will be void or terminated, thus the RoT holds valid between the two companies3. Gold Corp Ltd has demanded 1 Kilo of gold, stamped with Gold Corp seal. The company can claim the gold under the clause (i-a) of the RoT. This is a separate goods storage clause which states that until full payment has been received by Gold Corp for all gold supplied to GT Jewellers by Gold Corp Ltd. to GT Jewellers and at whatever time: property in the goods shall remain in the Company and such goods must be marked as belonging to the company and stored separately. This clause allows the Gold Corp Ltd. to reclaim 1 Kilo of gold as they are still unsold and in the possession of the buyer, who under the RoT was obligated to store the goods separately from goods of other parties and in an identifiable position4 till payment had been made by GT Jewelers. Although since the RoT did not consists of an extended clause of ‘allowing the seller to have the right to access the premises of the buyer in order to determine whether the obligation is being complied with’5, there is no assurety that GT Jewelers actually complied with having stored the unsold good in an identifiable position. Gold Corp Ltd. has ascertained that they claim ownership of ‘a tank containing 2 kilos of melted gold bullion’. Under i-b of the RoT, which states that, if GT Jewellers converted the supplied gold into any new product either by including some other product in the mixture and in whatever proportions such conversion will be considered under the rights of Gold Corp and beneficially and legally ownership will reside in Gold Corp, Gold Corp has legal rights to claim the 2 kilos of melted gold bullion. The melting of the bullion will be regarded as its conversion, but since it is in an identifiable form and actually supplied by the supplier6. The clause i-b is the expanded RoT, which allows the seller to claim right of title even after the processing of the sold product7. Gold Corp has claimed ownership from the liquidator of ‘150 gold and diamond engagement rings worth ?5,000 each’. Under the clause i-b of the RoT, the Gold Corp Ltd can also ascertain right to claim goods that have undergone change; involving mixture with other goods in whatever proportion, as until the payment of dews such conversion would also be considered to be effected on part of the company, and the new products will be under the ownership of Gold Corp. Such a clause is referred to as a ‘mixed goods clause’, which allows Gold Corp to claim the right of products which might lose their identity by being converted into other products8, but even after being changed into a ring or any other product the gold is still identifiable and retrievable9. If the Gold in the rings and jewellery manufactured by GT Jewellers is not identifiable it will leave the whole RoT void and unenforceable10. The final claim that the Gold Corp have laid upon the GT Jewellers is of worth ?25,000, representing proceeds of sale of gold by GT Jewelers Ltd to another jewellery manufacturer. The clause i-c of the Rot states that GT Jewellers will have the liberty to sell the gold and any new products that are made from it in the ordinary course of business on the basis that the proceeds of sale shall belong to the Company. The ‘proceeds of sale clause11’ thus allowing the Gold Corp Ltd. to lay claim on the ?25,000 of sales generated through the sales of products which had been made by the gold supplied by Gold Corp. If the goods for which the RoT is being enforced are unidentifiable, then it becomes a charge, which makes GT Jewellers the owner of the products but leaves Gold Corp with the right to sell GT Jewellers property or in this case products to reimburse the due amount12. Since the Charge arose as a result of mutual consent of both parties thus Gold Corp holds the position of an unsecured creditor13 The RoT allows Gold Corp to file for claims negotiated in the clauses but since it does not consist of a clause permitting Gold Corp to actually enter the premises of GT Jewellers and seize the goods that are unpaid for14, Gold Corp cannot enter the premises to secure their goods, as entering the premise of GT Jewellers will make it trespassing on their premises and can lead to legal action against Gold Corp15. The RoT des not have a clause signifying that in case of bankruptcy all dues by the debtor become immediately payable to Gold Corp, leaving Gold Corp as an insecure creditor, thus reducing the chances that Gold Corp will be reimbursed when the business undergoes sales, as initially the payments of secured creditors will be made16. Over all Gold Corp RoT fulfills some requirements, but since the company is an unsecured creditor it does not have significant chances of receiving the dues owed by GT Jewellers. Bibliography AHERNS LAWERS, ‘Retention of Title Clauses When Goods Are Mixed’, Aherns Lawyers [web page] (2013) accessed 11 January 2013. MCGRATH, ELAINE, ‘How Well Does Your Retention of Title Clause Protect You?’, Reddy Charlton [Web Page] (2012) , accessed 11 January 2013. HERMES, EULER ‘Retention of Title, Deliver goods – but with conditions attached’, Euler Hermes [web page] (2012) , accessed 11 Jan. 2013. INSOLVENCY DIRECT, ‘Retention of Title’, Insolvency Direct [web page] (2007) , accessed 11 Jan. 2013. LAW DONUT, ‘Getting Your Goods Back If You Aren’t Paid’, Law Donut [web page] (2013) accessed 11 January 2013. OUT-LAW, ‘Retention of title clauses’, Out-law [web page] (2011) , accessed 11 Jan. 2013. UTZ, CLAYTON, ‘Reconstruction and Insolvency, Retention of Title Clauses’, Clayton Utz [Web Document] (2008), , accessed 11 January 2013. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Advise Goldcorp Ltd Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Advise Goldcorp Ltd Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1466096-advise-goldcorp-ltd
(Advise Goldcorp Ltd Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Advise Goldcorp Ltd Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1466096-advise-goldcorp-ltd.
“Advise Goldcorp Ltd Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1466096-advise-goldcorp-ltd.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Advise Goldcorp Ltd

Advise to Crumbly Caravans Ltd

he ‘Crumbly Caravans ltd.... The Scottish Law of Contract,in regard to the law of agency,defines the relationship between a principal and an agent,as well as that between an agent and a Third Party,and gives clear guidelines on how each party should act towards each other… The most fundamental duty of an agent towards the principal is that; the agent has a duty to follow the instructions issued by the principal to the agent fully, and perform them as instructed (Macgrego & Davidson, 2008 p17)....
3 Pages (750 words) Coursework

Predictability of Stock Returns and Dividends

Successful stock market investing should not be equated with get-rich-quick schemes.... Skilful investment decisions alone cannot make you an instant millionaire or enormously rich overnight.... For that you need to be a speculator or a gambler with an inborn flair and instinctive feel for the market, combined with a willingness to take great risks....
49 Pages (12250 words) Coursework

Analysis of Land Law Case

The facts of this case relates as to whether clauses restraining the behaviour of mortgagors, in terms of re-lease of the mortgaged property under restrictive clauses relating to time and mode of further lease could be enforceable under the provisions of the relevant laws, especially in the event of a collateral contract specifying the terms of re-leasing....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

European Sovereign Debt Crisis 2010-12 and the Impact on Bond Markets

The European Sovereign Debt crisis was first brought into the global consciousness on 5 November 2009, when Greece introduced that its budget deficit was 12.... % of gross domestic product (GDP)- having grave impacts on the authority of the Euro and the European financial markets.... hellip; he Greece deficit was the first explicit sign that the Euro-zone was facing and had been facing severe problems in their financial structure and regulations, and these problems would go on to affect all the nations in the European nations. The European Sovereign debt crisis d not be contained as the problems only in the Greek region, given the economical and financial structure governing the European nations it was apparent that this crisis was a truly ‘European' crisis and couldn't be handled in isolation with any one country....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Retention of Title Clause Contract

In Clough Mills ltd v Martin 2 ,there is no problem in this type of clause unless it seeks to retain equitable or beneficial ownership.... It would be useful to examine the legal position of RoT clause before discussing the case.... In England Wales, Sale of Goods Act S.... 9 permits a seller to reserve the right… Thus, a seller with enough bargaining power can impose retention of title clause by virtue of this section and a case law known as Romalpa1....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework

Symptoms and Major Cases in Pharmacology

Mary is a 61-year-old waitress who has worked in environment with heavy smoking for 25 years, she complained of asthma like symptoms and was advised to limit her exposure to secondhand smoke.... She altered her schedule to a quieter shift in order to limit her exposure.... For a… She also noticed swelling around her ankles, but attributed it to the demands of being on her feet all day....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Collaborative Social Networking - Linux

The paper "Collaborative Social Networking - Linux" describes that IBM created a similar network, known as Beehive, which was designed for ensuring that all of this company's employees across the globe were connected.... Another example that has been discussed is that of InnoCentive, a web community....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

The Pros and Cons of Crowdsourcing

This paper is primarily based on the pros and cons of crowdsourcing.... It is considered an extremely genuine and imperative business idea.... Organizers use the services of unpaid distant volunteers to reach an established goal for a given business or a certain company....  … However, the meanings of crowdsourcing and expressions vary from discipline to discipline, but the fundamental initiative is to manage the public-oriented intelligence generally perform company jobs that a corporation is able to usually either carry out itself or subcontract the tasks to a 3rd party services provider....
21 Pages (5250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us