StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article I have chosen for reading was named in a quite provocative and intriguing manner - 'Bad management theories are destroying good management practices' The name of the article itself was the starting point which made me feel surprised…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices"

“Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices Surprises in JA1 The article I have chosen for reading was d in a quite provocative and intriguing manner - 'Bad management theories are destroying good management practices' (Ghoshal, 2005). The name of the article itself was the starting point which made me feel surprised. The author was brave enough to question the effectiveness of academic theories taught to students and applied in management and other relative business fields.

Thus, for example, Ghoshal (2005, p.75) claimed at the beginning of the article: “Our theories and ideas have done much to strengthen the management practices that we are all now so loudly condemning”. After reading this phrase I have naturally changed the usual way of my thinking and started to follow the ideas of the author. Idea that “academic research related to the conduct of business and management has had some very significant and negative influences on the practice of management” has left particular impact on me as well as desire for further investigation (Ghoshal, 2005, p.76). An overall style of the author surprised me by its boldness and open minded approach.

Ghoshal’s vision of amoral theories propagated by business schools, idea of necessity to reconsider corporate governance issue, idea of positive organizational scholarship and some other thoughts made me to think through. 2. Surprises in JA 2 The second journal article that I have chosen for further analysis also was given loud and provocative name – “'Damned by our own theories: contradictions between theories and management education” (Donaldson 2002, p.96). Here the author surprised me less than Ghoshal did, as the idea of contradictions in management education and practice has already occupied my mind after reading the first article.

However, Donaldson managed to explain in details why “there is a contradiction between the views expressed by some major contemporary social science theories taught in management schools and the assumptions on which management education is founded” (2002, p. 97). And it was quite surprising to read that economics and finance, strategy theory, judgmental bias theory, institutional theory and agency theory, are all somehow conflicting with one or another basic ideas of business and management education.

Such a statement of question made me feel not only surprised but even frustrated, as it assumes that students learning wrong theories which are not really applicable for 100% in real life. 3. The evidence Ghoshal has provided evidence for his assertions by referring to the recent business scandals such as Enron, Global Grossing, and Tyco where executives of the companies treated their employees in very bad manner, but granted themselves excessive stock options (Ghoshal 2005, p.76) and how these scandals are taught in business schools to future managers.

In addition to “real-life” examples, Ghoshal refers to various theories laid out for the reader in a very logical and clever manner. Thus, for example, he refers to the law of natural selection in biology (2005, 78) or the laws of physics and compares it with the social sciences, explaining thus that management theories fail to shape mental phenomena of human beings. Additionally, in order to generate evidence for his assertions, Ghoshal uses a roadmap of arguments and other graphical visuals to better explain his ideas, and also he refers to various authoritative literature sources.

Donaldson has examined five social science theories used in schools of business and management and has critically assessed all these theories by referring to academic sources and books. Thus, for example, he cited what does the agency theory says and then he cited contradictory view of what institutional theory says about managers (Donaldson 2002, p. 103). By presenting such a comparative analysis of the key theoretical ideas taught in business schools, Donaldson reflects contradictions. The author believes that combination of academic knowledge with practical outcomes might result in impermanent gains for organization’s competitive performance, but more permanent gains in its non-competitive performance environment (Donaldson 2002, p. 105). 4.

Comparison Introduction What can be more exciting for a student at business school than reading an article arguing that “academic research related to the conduct of business and management has had some very significant and negative influences on the practice of management” (Ghoshal 2002, p.76). or another article saying that “there is a contradiction between the views expressed by some major contemporary social science theories taught in management schools and the assumptions on which management education is founded” (Donaldson 2002, p.97)? While both these articles were written by different authors, they both argued that modern academic theories are not true and may have negative impact on practical management.

The authors of both articles present their ideas that business education taught to students as well as to executives does have significant contradictions (Donaldson, 2002) and fails to take into consideration mental phenomena (Ghoshal, 2005, p.80). And what is even more important some economic theories do impose danger to decisions of practicing managers (Ghoshal, 2002). While Donaldson carefully criticizes the five theories related to business by comparing the ideas of one and other and highlights some contradictory statements, Ghoshal provides a much broader and deeper analysis of the problem.

Thus, for example, Ghoshal radically states that even though economic theory is wrong, it can become right because managers who were taught this theory adapt their practical experience to the learned doctrines (2002, p.77). Also, in order to strengthen his position, Ghoshal confronts business science to physics, and clarifies that current “management theories are overwhelmingly causal or functional” which is impossible because ethics or morality do not conform to any laws as the law of natural selection in biology does (2002, p.78). Ghoshal view on management theory is far less optimistic than the view of Donaldson.

While Donaldson suggests that in order to improve management and business theories it is necessary to “specify the causal connections between managerially valued outcomes and practices” (2005, p.105), Ghoshal argues that it is not right, as analysis of “particular action of an individual caused by a particular intention” should not be considered as a causal explanation (2002, p.78). In addition to this, Ghoshal also uses as a reference an idea of “a paradigm-based gloomy vision” which is a significant barrier to better understanding of complex social phenomena (2002, p.82). In his article Ghoshal claims that social theory cannot be values-free and it has to be motivated ideologically (2002, p. 84). Donaldson in his research applies much less to the social phenomena than Ghoshal does.

Despite this contrast, there are some common ideas expressed by both Donaldson and Ghoshal. Thus, for example, both authors believe that it might be very helpful to focus on study of especially positive processes, outcomes and attributes of organizations and its stakeholders (Ghoshal, 2002, p. 86). Ghoshal names this approach as Positive Organizational Scholarship. While Donaldson does not provide his vision of actions that need to be taken by academic leaders, Ghoshal believes that the deans are responsible for introducing and leading some changes in both recruitment and promotion processes in their schools (2002, p.89). Conclusion Both authors believe that modern academic theories are not absolutely true and may have negative impact on practical management outcomes.

Donaldson concentrates his critique on five key business theories and Ghoshal focuses on the idea of social phenomena. While both Donaldson and Ghoshal use different arguments to support their vision, they also express some common ideas. The idea which both authors support is to focus on study of especially positive processes, outcomes and attributes of organizations and its stakeholders rather than to concentrate all efforts on negative business life experiences. Total number of words: 1228 References Donaldson, L 2002, 'Damned by Our Own Theories: Contradictions Between Theories and Management Education', Academy Of Management Learning & Education, 1, 1, pp.

96-106, Business Source Elite, EBSCOhost, viewed 30 October 2013. Ghoshal, S 2005, 'Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices', Academy Of Management Learning & Education, 1, pp. 75-91, JSTOR Arts & Sciences X, EBSCOhost, viewed 28 October 2013.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices Essay”, n.d.)
Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1489380-access-the
(Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices Essay)
Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1489380-access-the.
“Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1489380-access-the.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Bad Management Theories Are Destroying Good Management Practices

Provocative Theory Cycle of Inquiry

Theory and Management Name Institution Theory and Management Surprises in JA1 The author of the Theory and Management asserts that the link between theory and management practices has occupied the first decade of the present century.... The Evidence The author has used Mike's learning and Kieran is learning to show the application of academic theory within management practices.... Surprises in JA 2 The author has taken an in – depth analysis of how the application of management theories affects organizations business culture....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ghoshals Train of Thought

hellip; Business schools seem to derive instruction from scientific theories, which then meet pessimistic ideologies that when implemented, turn into negative management practices.... “Our theories and ideas have done much to strengthen the management practices that we are all now so loudly condemning” by “adoption of a particular theory and more at the incorporation”, which have “ ideologically inspired amoral theories” that are taught in business school(Ghoshal, 2005:76-76)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ethics and Social Responsiility of Corporations

And the search for the BEST ethical practices never seems to end.... Employees are observed blaming the management for their workload and pressure, the management on the other hand blames the external environment, the competitive forces which are global.... Arguments on, whether child labor is acceptable or not Does pollution in third world countries promote employment for individuals Is the meaning of good ethical behavior this that we justify all acts of ours through our views of what seems ethical If management set minimum employee wages, the organization can prosper because of the fact that the organization would be able to sell at cheaper costs thus increasing market shares rapidly....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Discussion of Quality Control

My management is fully aware of these risks.... ISO 9000 and the Baldrige certifications are used to specifically measure the business performance.... They are the standards that have to be fulfilled by an organization and… Q2.... There is some evidence that in the years immediately following Baldridge or ISO certification/accreditation, performance standards and attention to quality actually decline to levels below the build up to accreditation review....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Organizational change

This remains the fundamental element utilised in understanding the change management process being implemented.... The management members within the company should be made to understand the content which shall be contained within the proposed change.... The implementation of organisational change results from the present organisational situation being compared to expected position....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Critical Review Of Sumantra Ghoshal's Article

The paper "Critical Review Of Sumantra Ghoshal's Article" explores rationale of the article “Bad management practices are destroying good management practices” and links it with the critique of agency theory to realize whether this was responsible in aggravating the global financial crisis.... The surge in corporate scandals in the past has brought management practices taught in the management schools under attack.... I think the “scientific treatment” of business, which most management theories propagate, is indeed an inappropriate approach as has been indicated by Ghoshal (Ghoshal,2005)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Business Management Theories and Practices

This paper tells that there is a thin line between developed theories and management practices.... management practices have evolved over the years, and the four articles are cognizant of this particular fact.... The articles agree that the various theories that have been developed over the years have played a significant role in shaping management practices at different levels.... Various management practices are enhanced from the various theories that have been produced over time....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Western Approaches to Management and Leadership

 This paper critique the current Western approaches to management and leadership.... It shall demonstrate in-depth knowledge and understanding of the critical management theory and its application as an analytical tool for resolving problems in a post-modern organization.... hellip;  There are various leadership and management styles which are applied in business, in politics, and in society in general.... management refers to the science of securing aims and purposes through the people and member resources (Olum, 2004)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us