StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Law Case Analysis - Essay Example

Summary
The case of Gray v Thames Trains Limited and Network Rail Infrastructure Limited1 represents a significant development in negligence; it posed the question – will a claim of negligence be defeated by pubic policy if inextricably linked with the claimant’s own criminal…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Law Case Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Law Case Analysis"

Download file to see previous pages

The principle that was examined in this case was the defense of “ex turpi causa non oritur actio” (my cause of action cannot be based upon my own wrongdoing). This principle was first laid out in the case of Holman v Johnson, in which Lord Mansfield stared that the question to be examined is whether the plaintiff’s demand “is founded upon the ground of any immoral act or contract, or upon the ground of his being guilty of any thing which is prohibited by a positive law of this country.

”2 In this instance Claimant Gray was a victim of the Ladbroke Grove Rail crash on 5th October 1999. His physical injuries were minor but he suffered from acute Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, as a result of which he stabbed a stranger to death on 19th August 20013. The defendants in this case acknowledged their responsibility for their negligence and damages including lost earnings caused to the Plaintiff. But this acknowledgement extended only up to the date of the manslaughter, because subsequent to this date, his claim was inextricably tied up with his own criminal conduct.

Applying the test set out by Lord Mansfield above for contractual recoveries in negligence, the plaintiff’s demand did involve criminal conduct, establishing that the principle of ex turpi causa non oritur actio was applicable. This test was also affirmed in the case of Tinsey v Milligan4 where the Court stated that establishing illegality must of necessity, form a part of the plaintiff’s case. In the case of Gray v Thomas Trains5 negligence was established up to the date of Claimant Gray’s crime.

The defendants sought to prove that this illegal conduct precluded recoveries against negligence. This raises two issues (a) whether illegality precludes recoveries in every instance and (b) whether there was a break in the chain of causation of negligence caused by the

...Download file to see next pages Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Law Case Analysis

Franchise Law Case Analysis

The essay 'Franchise Law Case Analysis" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues on the franchise law case.... In the final analysis, Sally and JLow have a reasonable chance of success in rescinding their contracts with JLow Florida Cafe.... The concept of fair dealing and good faith was considered in the case of Payne v McDonald's Corp.... In this case, the franchisor's renewal was conditional upon the franchisee's consent to rebuild the restaurant....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Tort Law: Case Analysis

This paper 'Tort Law: case analysis' aims to provide guidance for understanding the nature of the case chosen for this assignment where one plaintiff named Jerry who was diagnosed with a think skull since childhood.... Tort Law: case analysis This paper aims to provide guidance for understanding the nature of the case chosen for this assignment where one plaintiff named Jerry who was diagnosed with a think skull since childhood.... The author studies the case damages within the context of Tort Law since it is the only law being practiced at SmallVille where this accident was taken place....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Contract Law Case Analysis

The study "Contract Law Case Analysis" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the contract law case.... In this case, there was a contract that was made between Igor and Jonquil since there was an offer that was made through advertisement by Igor that was accepted by Jonquil through the post.... For this case, there was a contract that was made between Igor and Jonquil since there was an offer that was made through advertisement by Igor that was accepted by Jonquil through the post....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Commercial Law Case Analysis

The author examines the case where the Respondent has fallen from the flying fox while playing.... The facts of the case are: the height of the Flying Fox handle is 2.... In this case, this was not to be found.... Summary of Decision: The Judges in the Appeal court considered the following stance and the facts above to come to a conclusion on the case: 1.... The Judges found that this was a case under the causation principle....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Business Law Case Analysis

f it was not the intention of the parties that time should be of and Section # of Business Law Case Analysis Plaintiff: Ramirez Defendant: Nguyen Relevant Facts 1.... Therefore, the law binds the plaintiff to deliver the building to the defendant on an agreed time.... Therefore, the law binds the plaintiff to deliver the building to the defendant on an agreed time....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Business Law Case Analysis

The issue is about a drug trafficking case.... This case is against Cary.... The issue is about a drug trafficking case.... This case is against Cary.... The main legal law on this case is drug trafficking.... mportance of the legal issue to the situation at hand The drug trafficking case against Cary makes Alicia to be compelled to run for the State's Attorney post.... In that case, Lemond Bishop is the leading drug trafficker in Chicago....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Immigration Law Case Analysis

The report "Immigration Law Case Analysis" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the case of immigration law.... ?? One year on: an analysis of UK measures to protect trafficked persons.... Conventionally, qualitative research approach is used to produce information on a case study.... Legal advice is sought in this case because of the importance of prompt access to specialist legal advice.... In this case, Sheila did not apply for asylum at her point of entry....
10 Pages (2500 words) Report

Tort Law Case Analysis

"Tort Law Case Analysis" paper examines the case of Lucas, a Mathematics teacher at Walford High School who has taught for over 2 years in the school.... TORT Law Case Analysis Introduction This paper examines the case of Lucas, a Mathematics teacher at Walford High School who has taught for over 2 years in the school.... ritical case analysis ... The first part will set out the fundamental rules relating to employers' liabilities in tort in this case....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us