StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of Their Leadership - Movie Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of Their Leadership " discusses that Malcolm X and Gandhi were two extraordinary thinkers and highly charismatic leaders of the twentieth century with completely different philosophical outlooks and approaches…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of Their Leadership
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of Their Leadership"

This paper makes further brief comparisons with respect to their style of leadership, handling of conflict, relating with others, and the evolution of their political views based on the two films.

The way Gandhi used nonviolence effectively against the ruling British was to create no more than civil disobedience, for example by encouraging people to refuse to obey certain unjust laws and refuse to pay taxes. However, his approach was to endure suffering and not attempt to perpetuate the cycle of violence. He thus took a spiritually higher stance. His leadership was an inspiration to Martin Luther King and far removed from that of Malcolm X. The approach of Malcolm X on the other hand is clearly portrayed at the opening of the movie with his inflammatory speech.

The history of both leaders also involved a famous march and it is worth exploring this for comparative purposes. In one of the most picturesque parts of the film, Gandhi is shown leading a march to the sea to teach people how to make salt despite a prohibition to do so. The purpose was thus to improve the well-being of his people through self-sufficiency while at the same time demonstrating opposition to the British salt tax. Gandhi’s philosophy was to make people focus first on self-discipline before opposing oppressors. This approach based on compassion and truth is known as ‘satyagraha’.

Malcolm’s march was to a hospital in Harlem, in which a Muslim was recovering from police brutality. It is after this episode that Malcolm advanced as a leader in the Nation of Islam. There was another peaceful march for civil rights on Washington in his time, but Malcolm was against it. Thus, Malcolm’s aim was to highlight oppression rather than teach something that would be practically useful for his people.

As far as the accuracy of the films is concerned, Malcolm X is based more or less faithfully according to his autobiography. The film Gandhi is also historically accurate and Gandhi too left an autobiography, but its title, ‘The stories of my experiments with the truth’, speaks for itself. Gandhi was always obsessed with truth but for Malcolm, this stage in life came much later. However, it was his constant openness to the truth that actually facilitated the eventual change.

In terms of their evolution then, or rather change of political views; those of Malcolm X was most dramatic. In showing this, the movie makes good use of real footage from Malcolm X’s pilgrimage to Makkah and meetings with other Muslim political leaders. In the end, Malcolm’s conflict became internalized and he had to deal with it and come to terms with the reality before he could become somewhat more like Gandhi who was already more mature. The change was so significant that the new Malcolm denounced racism and aligned himself with mainstream Islam based on ideas of peace and brotherhood.

In short, Gandhi’s style of leadership was more spiritual with a focus on developing self-discipline as well as promoting self-sufficiency. He handled conflict in a peaceful way and tried to champion peaceful relations. In contrast, Malcolm X knew and practiced no means other than violence, adopted a racist ideology, and thus led his people to be in direct conflict with others, until that is, his inner struggle and search for the truth transformed him.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of their Leadership a Movie Review, n.d.)
Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of their Leadership a Movie Review. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1738865-malcolm-x-and-ghandi
(Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of Their Leadership a Movie Review)
Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of Their Leadership a Movie Review. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1738865-malcolm-x-and-ghandi.
“Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of Their Leadership a Movie Review”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1738865-malcolm-x-and-ghandi.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Malcolm X and Gandhi: A Philosophical Comparison of Their Leadership

Socrates and Martin Luther King and Malcolm X

(Cline) Martin Luther King was inspired by Mahatma gandhi's sayings and was led to believe that non-violence could be used by blacks to obtain civil rights in America.... Martin Luther King was inspired by Mahatma gandhi's sayings and was led to believe that non-violence could be used by blacks to obtain civil rights in America.... The one statement by gandhi which deeply affected him was “Through our pain we will make them see their injustice” ...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Leadership Exhibition (Mahatma Ghandi

Name Institution Course Instructor Date leadership Exhibition (Mahatma Ghandi) Introduction Mahatma Gandhi during his childhood.... This report therefore seeks to demonstrate that good leadership can be assembled not only through the usual cunning game of political maneuvers but through the cogent example of a morally superior conduct of life Charismatic leadership style of Mahatma Gandhi Mahatma Gandhi preaches to a group of people.... As such, scholars have considered his leadership style as charismatic....
4 Pages (1000 words) Coursework

The Contrast Between Martin Luther King and Malcolm X

The paper "The Contrast Between Martin Luther King and malcolm x" highlights that Malcolm's exclusively black approach to the racial inequality problem may have in the end, achieved the equality he dreamed of; on the other hand, it would likely have deeply divided.... malcolm x espoused a radical approach to equality much like Karl Marx; he believed there could be no social change unless those desirous of it forcefully instituted it.... Their dissimilar legacies are evident in the modern perception of their work, today while Martin Luther is considered the peaceful champion of civil rights movements; malcolm x has been frozen history as the angry black radical, which he was until his visit to meccas after which mellowed his approach....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Mohandas Gandis and Imam Husseins Leaderships

In fact, a critical analysis of Hussein's and gandhi's leaderships will necessarily reveal that Gandhi took the only lesson of adhering to one's righteous claim nonviolently from the example of Imam Hussein's martyrdom.... Name: Course: Tutor: Date: A Comparative Analysis of Mohandas Gandi's and Imam Hussein's Leaderships From Kouzes-Posner Framework of leadership Mohandas K.... Gandhi was a great sociopolitical leader whose leadership seems to validate “Kouzes-Posner leadership Framework” to a large extent....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Ways in Which Martin Luther King Jr Influenced the World

By this time he started associating with and attained leadership positions in civil rights movements.... He took leadership of the first recorded modern-day Negro demonstration in December 1955.... Martin Luther King, early in his childhood had exposure to philosophical and spiritual values....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Leadership of Ghandi

In the paper 'leadership of Gandhi,' the author discusses a great who had the talent of getting a massive amount of people to follow him and his beliefs.... The author states that all of gandhi's methods were called 'Ahimsa.... One very effective 'Ahimsa' was gandhi's Nationwide day of prayer and fasting.... More of gandhi's methods to achieve his ultimate goal of an independent India were marching and making speeches.... gandhi took many followers to Darishima Salt Works, at which they made two lines formed of men while women were setting up hospital tents nearby....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Autobiography of Malcolm X

malcolm x was born, Malcom Little to Earl Little and Louise Helen Norton.... Malcom's life was one of hardships, and disappointments malcolm x was born, Malcom Little to Earl Little and Louise Helen Norton.... from serving his prison term, Malcom joined the nation of Islam and adopted the name malcolm x.... The press treated malcolm x with disdain and labeled him a troublemaker....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X Comparison

and malcolm x Comparison" provides a comprehensive discussion on Martin Luther King Jr.... and malcolm x.... and malcolm x, this also provides an extensive comparison between the two prior to their social environment and embraced philosophies, especially on the notion with regard to the fight of the Blacks for their civil rights.... here were noticeable differences in the way how Martin Luther King and malcolm x grew before they became prominent leaders of the blacks....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us